
In Episode 471, Jeff Belanger and Ray Auger investigate the site of a former cottage in Waterville, Maine, that made the news in 1895 for being so profoundly haunted. Strange taps, knocks, and sounds plagued the cottage that had been moved to this downtown location a decade earlier from the nearby town of Fairfield. To spirit investigators had a night they’ll never forget.
BECOME A LEGENDARY PATRON:
https://www.patreon.com/NewEnglandLegends
CREDITS:
Produced and hosted by: Jeff Belanger and Ray Auger
Edited by: Ray Auger
Theme Music by: John Judd
SUBSCRIBE TO THE PODCAST FOR FREE:
Apple Podcasts/iTunes | Spotify | Pandora | Amazon Podcasts | TuneIn | iHeartRadio
JOIN OUR SUPER-SECRET:
New England Legends Facebook Group

EPISODE TRANSCRIPT:
*A note on the text: Please forgive punctuation, spelling, and grammar mistakes. Like us, the transcripts ain’t perfect.
[SMALL CITY NOISE/CARS ETC.]
RAY: So we’re walking down the sidewalk in the center of Waterville, Maine.
JEFF: We are. The fire station is across the street, there’s a chain pharmacy next to us, there’s the post office over there, and plenty of small businesses and shops are all within view around us.
RAY: This is a weird, X-shaped intersection where Main Street, or Rt. 104, intersects with Elm Street and College Avenue.
JEFF: Today this looks like the bustling center of a downtown—because it is!
RAY: We’re also a stone’s throw from the banks of the Kennebec River.
JEFF: You can see a lot of old mills on the other side of the water—which also gives us a clue about the early history of Waterville.
RAY: That makes sense.
JEFF: Now imagine this same area 130 years ago. Waterville was about half the size in population. This would have felt more like a village back then. A village with a peculiar cottage of a house that would have stood just about where we are today. A cottage that grabbed a lot of attention… because it was so very haunted.
[INTRO]
JEFF: Hello, I’m Jeff Belanger. Welcome to Episode 471 of the New England Legends podcast.
RAY: And I’m Ray Auger. Thank you for riding along with us as we chronicle every wicked strange legend in New England. People often ask us where we get our story ideas. The short answer is: You! Thank you for contacting us through our website with your local tales of ghosts, monsters, aliens, roadside oddities, and so much more. We appreciate it!
JEFF: That we do. We’re glad to have you with us on our adventures each and every week. New episodes every Thursday, so please subscribe to our podcast wherever you get your podcasts. It’s free!
RAY: We’ll go searching for this Waterville, Maine, haunt right after this word from our sponsor.
SPONSOR
[SMALL CITY NOISE/CARS ETC.]
RAY: Waterville, Maine, is located about 15 miles north of Maine’s capitol of Augusta. Its history goes way back to when it was a Wabanaki settlement, it became a colonial trading post in 1653, a permanent settlement in 1754, and incorporated as its own town in 1802. As we mentioned earlier, the Kennebec River powered many old mills as the town grew over the decades. Waterville is also home to Colby College and Thomas College.
JEFF: Yes, today it’s a quaint college town on the banks of the river. But there was a time when a dark and spooky spirit plagued a nearby cottage. To investigate this haunt, let’s head back to the year 1895.
[TRANSITION]
RAY: It’s early April of 1895 here in Waterville, Maine. Grover Cleveland is president of the United States, Henry Cleaves is the governor of Maine, and “My Best Girl’s a New Yorker” by Edward M. Favor is the number one song. Economically, times have been tough the last couple of years. America seems to be running out of money.
JEFF: Here in Waterville, locals are doing what they have to do to find work and save what they can. Thankfully there’s a lot of mills running along the river. There’s opportunities here for work.
RAY: Which may explain why Charles Luce (LUCY – LIKE GIRL’S NAME) moved his cottage here ten years ago from the nearby town of Fairfield. He had the cottage placed on the east side of Waterville and Fairfield Road near the center of town.
JEFF: The cottage is a box of a house. Luce doesn’t live here, he rents it out to people looking for an inexpensive place to live near the town center and the mills who offer jobs. (BEAT) Let’s head inside.
[WALKING]
[DOOR OPENS / CLOSES]
RAY: Yeah, this isn’t much of a cottage. It’s a square house, the kitchen is in the back, a small living area, fireplace, and a bedroom. You can pretty much see it all from right here at the front door.
JEFF: A simple, working class home. But those who move in… don’t seem to stay very long.
RAY: Why’s that?
JEFF: Something has tenants unnerved. It’s like….
[SOFTLY TAP TAP TAP]
RAY: Do you hear that?
JEFF: Yeah.
[TAP TAP TAP]
JEFF: It’s sounds like it’s coming from over here…
[WALKING]
RAY: Now I don’t hear it.
[TAP TAP TAP]
RAY: Wait… now it’s coming from the other side. (BEAT) This is weird.
[DOOR OPENS / SLAMS]
JEFF: And just like that… another tenant leaves. (BEAT) This continues for months. More tenants move in because of the cheap rent and good location. But then…
[GHOSTLY WHISPER]
RAY: Okay, that’s just freaky….
[LOUD SLAM]
RAY/JEFF: What was that?!
RAY: I have no idea.
[SCRATCHING SOUNDS ACROSS THE WALL SLOW]
JEFF: Could that be a rodent or something?
RAY: I guess, but this sounds different than a mouse in the wallboards or ceiling.
JEFF: The unexplained noises are more than most residents can take. They soon find another place to live.
RAY: It’s now early December. This little cottage has earned quite the reputation for being haunted. Enough so that two Spiritualists have decided to spend the night and investigate the ghosts.
[DOOR OPENS/CLOSES]
JEFF: The two spiritualists are men in their late 40s. They have two small duffle bags with them.
[ZIPPER]
JEFF: They’re setting aside a pad a pencil near the stand by the bed. They have some candles. They’ve brought bread flour too.
RAY: One of the men is sprinkling flour across the floor around the kitchen and living area of the cottage. Why are they doing that?
JEFF: They’re going to look for footprints in the light coating of flour on the floor. If we all stay away from the flour, and later we see footprints, then we know it was something not from our plane of existence.
RAY: Okay… if we see footprints in the white dust, I’m out of here.
(PAUSE)
RAY: Night falls as the two spiritualists observe the cottage.
[TAP TAP TAP]
JEFF: As if on cue, the tapping has started again. But then it stops.
[SCRATCHING NOISE AGAIN]
JEFF: There’s that scratching again! It sounds like it’s scratching across the air—not even on the walls.
RAY: This is unnerving. It’s getting late, so the two spirit investigators decide to turn in. They climb into bed… and soon fall asleep.
[SLEEPING NOISES?]
[HEAVY BOOTSTEPS ON THE FLOOR]
JEFF/RAY: Huh… what is that?!
[BEDROOM DOOR OPENS]
JEFF: The men have both jumped out of bed.
RAY: I can feel something here.
JEFF: Yeah, it’s strange. Almost like a static energy.
RAY: If you’re a spirit… will you make your presence known?
JEFF: One of the investigators has grabbed the pencil and is staring blankly in the corner of the room.
[PENCIL ON PAPER]
JEFF: He’s doing automatic writing… it’s when a medium—in this case this man—allows a spirit to use his hand to potentially write a message.
[PENCIL STOPS]
RAY: Woah… did you feel that?
[LIGHT WHOOOSH]
RAY: The room feels different now.
JEFF: It does. Hey… Ray, here, check out the message written on the automatic writing paper.
[HANDS PAPER]
RAY: It’s tough to read. There’s a lot of scribbles on the paper… but yeah… I think I can make it out. It says: My body is concealed in this house. Find it, give it proper burial and more will be revealed unto you.
JEFF: Wow… that’s frightening. Where would you hide a body in a cottage this small?
RAY: I have no idea. The walls don’t look thick enough to hide a body. And the house has only been in this spot for a decode or so. Could it be…
JEFF: Under the house?
RAY: Maybe?
JEFF: And check out the flour on the floor.
RAY: I don’t see any footprints. But I definitely heard those boot-stomps a few minutes ago.
JEFF: It’s the following morning when the two spiritualist leave the haunted cottage in Waterville. They report their findings to the Sun-Journal of Lewiston, Maine. And that takes us back to today.
[TRANSITION]
[SMALL TOWN TRAFFIC]
JEFF: Pretty much everything we know about this story came from the December 14, 1895 Sun Journal of Lewiston, Maine.
RAY: Obviously the cottage is long gone now. We’re standing in the parking lot of a modern drug store chain.
JEFF: Right. The house isn’t here anymore.
RAY: Still, I have some questions.
JEFF: Sure.
RAY: Were there more investigations of this cottage?
JEFF: If there were, the newspaper didn’t cover those stories.
RAY: Okay, was a skeleton ever unearthed when they built newer buildings?
JEFF: Not that made the papers. And here’s the thing. It seems like a lazy paranormal trope when someone says: Yeah, deaths and murders didn’t always make the papers. That’s not true at all. William Randolph Hearst of Hearst media fame said in the 1890s: If it bleeds, it leads. So yes, death and destruction always made the news. That was true before the 1890s too, but Hearst made it sound poetic.
RAY: In a dark and awful way, sure.
JEFF: BUT… construction crews finding a skeleton… that could get covered up. It happens.
RAY: Why would that get covered up?
JEFF: Because when a construction crew—or homeowner for that matter—unearths a skeleton, you’re supposed to call the police.
RAY: Yeah, I would hope so!
JEFF: The police bring in a medical examiner. They need to figure out if it’s a new skeleton and maybe there’s foul play involved, or if it’s an old family burial ground, or maybe it’s Native burial ground.
RAY: I see… no matter what, your construction project could stop for days, weeks, months, or maybe forever if it’s of archeological importance.
JEFF: Right. So sometimes a construction crew finds a skeleton and they just bury it beneath whatever they’re building because they can’t afford to get the project shut down for weeks or potentially forever. I’m not saying that’s what DID happen, I’m just saying it’s possible. It’s also possible those Spiritualists got the wrong message.
RAY: Or maybe since the house had been moved from its original location in Fairfield, Maine, maybe the ghost story began back there?
JEFF: The reality is we’ll never know. But we do know that a humble little house that once stood very close to where we are right now in Waterville, Maine, once made enough supernatural waves that it made the news. People investigated… and got more than they bargained for.
[OUTTRO]
RAY: And that takes us to After the Legend where we dive deeper into this week’s story and sometimes veer off course.
JEFF: After the Legend is brought to you by our mighty patreon patrons! Thank you, patrons for making all of this possible. Our patrons are a group of insiders who get early ad-free access to new episodes, plus bonus episodes and content that no one else gets to hear. And they get access to our entire archive of shows through a unique RSS feed that they can play in their favorite podcast player so you have it all in one place. It’s just $3 bucks per month, but it helps a lot, especially if there’s enough of you. We don’t have a big podcast network behind us, we’ve got you. To sign up, head to patreon.com/newenglandlegends.
To see some pictures related to this week’s story, click on the link in our episode description, or go to our website and click on Episode 471
Here’s another way you can help our growing community of legend hunters! First, you can subscribe to the show because it’s free wherever you get your podcasts. Then you can post a review for us—that helps others find us in a crowded sea of podcasts. You can also tell your friends about us. Post our episodes to your social media. It all goes a long way and Jeff and I appreciate it.
We’d like to thank our sponsors, thank you so much to our patreon patrons, and our theme music is by John Judd.
Until next time remember… the bizarre is closer than you think!